Friday, April 6, 2018

Relationship Tug-of-War



My husband and I have been married almost twenty years.  In that time, we have had plenty of disagreements.  Many of these disagreements were directly related to our in-law relationships.  Both sets of in-laws were demanding or critical in different ways.  Both expected my husband or I to conform to set family norms.  Neither of us felt appreciated by the other family.  And many times, the demands of the extended family left my husband and I feeling caught in the middle of a nasty game of relationship tug-of-war. 

Over the last five years, we have been able to set healthy boundaries and to distance ourselves when needed.  As a couple, our relationship conflict was reduced significantly by how effective we have been at making and standing by these boundaries.

As my husband and I encourage our own children to date, we have stayed up late talking about what kind of in-laws we want to be.  Our greatest fear has been that, like us, our children will not want to spend time with their parents when they are grown.  However, we have discovered that there is much we can do as in-laws to encourage, build and enjoy powerful positive relationships with our children and their future spouses. 

Some of these same ideas which have taken us twenty years to figure out ourselves were presented in the reading from Harper, J. M. & Olsen, S. F. (2005). "Creating Healthy Ties With In-Laws and Extended Families." In C. H. Hart, L.D. Newell, E. Walton, & D.C. Dollahite (Eds.), Helping and healing our families: Principles and practices inspired by "The Family: A Proclamation to the World" (pp. 327-334). Salt Lake City, UT: Deseret Book Company.

Here are some of the highlights…

New couples can focus on establishing a new marital identity.  In-law parents can encourage this by withholding judgement and practicing acceptance and charity to the new in-law.

Sensitive parents-in-law recognize how important it is for the new couple to establish their own traditions and have individual time together on special occasions.  Refraining from pressuring the couple to attend all family events while still continuing to invite with grace will be very important.

Wise parents understand that their parental role continues in love, concern, and encouragement, but never in a realm of domination, control, regulation, supervision, or imposition.

Parents will do better to listen and not impose their opinions or feelings. Intrusion by in-laws, both physically by too many visits and phone calls, and emotionally by too many strongly held opinions is to be avoided at all costs.

When married children are treated with respect and love in this matter, they are more likely to want to spend more time with parents and extended family. Demands, expectations, manipulations, ultimatums, threats, and emotional blackmailing tend to strain or destroy relationships.

When new roles are being defined for both parents and children, it helps parents to realize that they have to make adjustments that may not always be comfortable. This is normal and the discomfort may disappear with time and effort.



Parents who are secure in their relationships with their children understand that married children can be emotionally close without always having to be present. These children, in turn, have a sense of their parents' own security so they don't have to always be near them to take care of them emotionally. Parents who are secure in their relationships with their children understand that married children can be emotionally close without always having to be present. These children, in turn, have a sense of their parents' own security so they don't have to always be near them to take care of them emotionally.